Service and Claims

Below is the company contact information for claims and customer service (policy changes, billing questions).  Be sure to have your policy number when calling.  Some companies allow you to file claims and process changes on their website.

Travelers

www.travelers.com
Claims: 1.800.252.4633
Customer Service: 877.872.8737
For Claims: Click here

Alfa Alliance

www.alfaaic.com
Claims & Customer Service: (800) 989-6053  M-F 8 am – 4:45 pm
Claims After Hours – Emergency Only (Serious Bodily Injury or Extensive Damage):  (800) 394-8642 ext. 425 
Claims After Hours – Non Emergency: (800) 394-8642

Progressive

www.progressiveagent.com
Customer Service: 1-800-876-5581
Claim0-274-4s: 1-80499
Roadside Assistance: 1-888-776-2778

The Hartford

www.thehartford.com
Claims: 800-243-5860
Customer Service: 800-624-5578

Foremost

www.foremost.com
Claims: 1-800-527-3907
Customer Service: 1-800-527-3905

Selective Flood

www.floodonline.com
Customer Service & Claims: 877-348-0552

Brethren Mutual Insurance Company

www.bmic.com
Policyholder Services Department: 1-800-621-4264

Rockingham Mutual

www.rockinghamgroup.com
Customer Service: 800-572-4015
Claims: 800-662-5246

*For all other companies, contact Members Assurance.

If you prefer, you may contact our office at 757-523-5352 to process policy changes Monday – Friday
9 am – 5 pm.